Building a Culture of Innovation in Associations

A brain materializing into small pixels April 28, 2025 By: Chris Vaughan, Ph.D.

To stay relevant, associations need to create environments where new ideas flourish, experimentation is routine, and member needs guide every decision.

Innovation isn’t a lightning strike—it’s a garden. It needs the right soil (culture), the right tools (process), and dedicated gardeners (people) to grow. In associations, innovation is often overshadowed by tradition, constrained by risk aversion, or siloed into one-off initiatives. But in today’s environment of accelerating change, associations must treat innovation not as an occasional project but as a cultural imperative.

This article explores how forward-thinking association leaders embed innovation into their organizational DNA by empowering people, systematizing experimentation, and anchoring in mission and member value.

Rethinking Innovation for Associations

Too often, innovation is misunderstood as synonymous with massive disruption or breakthrough technology. But in reality, it can be as simple—and as powerful—as a new member onboarding journey, a revised dues model, or a fresh approach to volunteer engagement.

For associations, innovation means meeting emerging member needs in new ways. The key is relevance, whether launching a micro-credential, building a new member segment, or eliminating dated practices that no longer serve. As Todd Unger, the American Medical Association's chief experience officer, says, “We have to meet our members where they are, not where we wish they would be.”

One Sequence Consulting client, a professional certification organization, used member feedback to redesign its core offering into modular, self-paced tracks. This shift improved engagement and opened new revenue streams—proof that incremental innovation often has the greatest impact.

Associations that build the capacity to innovate, not just the intent, will thrive as the environment shifts from generational change to AI disruption. As one Sequence client CEO said, “Our job isn’t to predict the future. It’s to prepare our organization to adapt to whatever future comes.”

Associations don’t need more ideas. They need the right conditions for ideas to take root.

Empowering People: Innovation Starts With Trust

Innovation lives or dies on culture—and culture begins with trust. Associations need to lower the cost of failure. Teams must feel safe floating unpolished ideas and challenging the status quo. Psychological safety isn’t a buzzword; it’s the prerequisite for innovation.

This also means flattening traditional hierarchies. Innovation can’t be the job of a task force alone. Everyone, from front-line staff to volunteer leaders, should feel ownership.

One of our clients, a national professional organization, established a cross-departmental "innovation circle" that meets monthly to share micro-experiments underway. These ranged from testing new onboarding messages to piloting user-generated content in newsletters. The visibility and encouragement helped normalize iteration across teams.

Associations should train for innovation, recognize initiative, and celebrate learning—not just outcomes.

Making Experimentation Systematic

Innovation is not a department. It’s a discipline. Associations must avoid "big bet" thinking and embrace continuous, low-risk testing.

Borrowing from the agile playbook, this means prototyping fast, gathering feedback early, and refining constantly. Member personas, journey mapping, and qualitative feedback loops provide invaluable guidance on where to start.

A savvy client of ours adopted a quarterly "test and learn" cycle tied to its strategic goals. Each team selected a small hypothesis to test—such as a new messaging frame for lapsed members or a revamped volunteer recruitment ask. They shared outcomes, lessons, and next steps in an open forum. It wasn’t always neat, but it built momentum.

Creating internal structures—like cross-functional teams, learning budgets, or sandbox tools—supports this behavior. Start small. Solve a known pain point. Build from there.

Leveraging Technology Thoughtfully

Technology is often treated as innovation itself. But as Bill Gates said, "Technology is a magnifier—it amplifies whatever culture and strategy you already have."

Associations should anchor every tech decision in member value. The goal isn’t automation for its own sake—it’s better personalization, more vibrant communities, and seamless access to knowledge.

One Sequence client used CRM data to identify a drop-off point in member onboarding. A simple series of personalized nudges dramatically increased engagement in the first 90 days—no new platform, just smarter use of what they had.

Investing in data infrastructure is also critical. With the right data, you can spot trends, surface unmet needs, and personalize experiences that members didn’t even know they wanted.

Being the Change: The Leader’s Role

Ultimately, the tone is set at the top. Association leaders must model curiosity, vulnerability, and openness to change. That means making space for strategic thinking, not just firefighting.

Great leaders don’t pretend to have all the answers. They cultivate environments where listening and learning are the norm. They acknowledge friction points openly and remove barriers to creativity.

Aligning innovation efforts with the mission helps everyone stay focused. The leader's role is to connect the dots and help the team understand that the goal is not to be trendy but to become essential.

Conclusion: Make Innovation Your Culture, Not a Project

True innovation is a culture, not a campaign. Associations that empower people, experiment continuously, and evolve with member needs will be best positioned for long-term impact.

Start small. Learn fast. Stay human-centered. Because, in the end, innovation isn’t about being flashy—it’s about being relevant.

Chris Vaughan, Ph.D.

Chris Vaughan, Ph.D., is cofounder and chief strategy officer of Sequence Consulting.